Ask Prof. Wolff

rdw_speaking.png
 
Have a question for Professor Wolff? Want to suggest a topic or article? UPVOTE your favorite questions or submit your own. Top suggestions will be given a video answer on YouTube.
 
Professor Wolff receives hundreds of questions per week covering a wide array of topics, from economics and politics, to historical movements and current events. While Professor Wolff does his best to reply to some questions on Economic Update with Richard D. Wolff, he's received more questions than can be answered individually. Prof. Wolff will now provide video answers to his favorite questions on this page.
 
Select "upvote" or "downvote" to promote certain questions. You must be logged in to vote or submit your own.
Please check your e-mail for a link to activate your account.

How could we transform professional sports leagues into worker co-ops?

With all the recent news about professional sports teams leaving their communities for more profitable venues, I've been thinking about how all these leagues (MLB, NFL, NHL, NBA) are structured (that is, in a capitalistic, top-down fashion). How could we go about reorganizing these leagues in a more democratic way that prioritizes players, fans, and their surrounding communities over profit?

2 comments Share

How would you recommend to read Capital, Volume I?

I'm thinking of reading it with a couple friends. Should we get David Harvey's companion? How about starting at Part 8, then reading from the beginning? etc. Thank you.

Richard Wolff posted an official response

Capital - and indeed, all three volumes - is an important book to read because (1) it remains a foundational work in how and why to criticize the capitalist system, (2) it is thus a good balancing companion to the works of Adam Smith and David Ricardo whose foundational works in economics were both highly celebratory of the capitalist system, (3) it can enable you to pursue the vast accumulated literature of Marxian economics. There are several books that can help you work through Marx's Capital and David Harvey's is certainly one of those. Please excuse my immodesty but let me also recommend the chapter devoted to Marx's economics in the following book: R.D. Wolff and S. A. Resnick, Contending Economic Theories: Neoclassical, Keynesian and Marxian (Cambridge: MIT Press 2012). This book also clarifies systematically how Marxian economics differs from the mainstream neoclassical economics and also from Keynesian economics.

Preview the text online or order your examination copy at http://mitpress.mit.edu/CET

2 comments Share

It is looking likely that Donald Trump will roll back financial regulations on banks

you probably caught whiff of this by now, but i would love to hear your take on what will happen in your weekly and/or monthly economic update if trump takes things in this direction, or even took it to it's extremes. How do you think getting rid of the dodd-frank (and possibly many other regulations) could affect both the American and global economy? Do you think this could result in banks exploding in a similar mortgage crisis like what happened in 2008? Sources:

https://www.bloomberg.com/politics/articles/2017-02-03/trump-to-halt-obama-fiduciary-rule-order-review-of-dodd-frank

http://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-trump-wealth-fiduciary-idUSKBN15I199

1 comment Share

Is a sizeable middle class (50-60-% of population), a natural product of a Capitalist society?

Is a middle class bigger than a relatively few percent of the population, an artificial creation? It seems that in every country ruled by Capitalist elites that never had a "New Deal"-type installation of social programs, poverty dominates and there is a small middle class. Is America's large middle class an artificlal creation via the Democratic-Socialist policies from the New Deal? Does unfettered Capitalism naturally create anything but a SMALL middle class?

1 comment Share

Why have two organizations with basically the same name?

Your organization, Democracy at Work, and the US Federation of Worker Cooperatives's sister Democracy at Work Institute.

Richard Wolff posted an official response

Just coincidence; the two organizations have no relationship, never did, and just reflect that the worker coop idea is basically about bringing democracy into the workplace and is an idea whose time has come.

3 comments Share

if a crash comes, which is the safest haven for my retirement funds?

A lot of commentary seems to issue the warning that the wheels of the capitalist system are starting to wobble. As a retiree, I am acutely aware of not putting all my eggs into one basket: but the problem we all face is that everything seems interconnected. What is your advice for what would be a good set of diverse investments for the just-retired?

Richard Wolff posted an official response

I make it a rule never to give advice when I have not first ascertained the financial details of the person to whom I am offering the advice. So I cannot offer it to you in these circumstances either. I can say to you that capitalism has a long history of cycles that basically run usually every 4-7 years. The last cyclical downturn in the US (and elsewhere too) was in 2009-2010. You can do the arithmetic. Be extraordinarily cautious because the fast-worsening political instabilities overlay the underlying economic instabilities.

2 comments Share

Big U.K. grocery store trialing robots to automate further

Big U.K. grocery store trialing robots to automate further. Ocado trials fruit-picking robot http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/technology-38808925

1 comment Share

We Own It - Europe and Worker Coop Movement

Prof. Wolff, I wanted to pass along this campaign aimed at young people and a note on the worker coop movement in Europe. You may have been aware of both! They would make useful comments for Economic Update or your monthly lecture in NYC. http://www.we-own-it.coop/home.html http://www.cecop.coop/European-Parliament-calls-for-the-promotion-of-cooperatives Keep fighting. We really appreciate it.

2 comments Share

Can Complementary Currencies be used to bootstrap worker-owend businesses?

Could a municipality/city council impose a tax that required payment in the form of a "digital muni" currency, and then use that generated demand for the "muni" to fund worker-owned businesses? Anchor institutions could provide recurring demand, and a marcora law type equivalent could provide the cash needed to purchase machinery/means of production made outside the muni-area. Have you heard of the "Miracle of Worgl?" What are your views on demurrage currencies? I've come to a realization, which is possibly wrong as they sometimes are, that money underpins all social relations... that the ruling classes have chosen a form of money that accumulates power is no surprise, and I believe that demurrage would be way to nullify that aim. Thank you, -Jon.

Richard Wolff posted an official response

I would agree that the capitalist system both inherited money and monetary systems from the feudalism or other systems that preceded it but also transformed money and monetary systems so that they were more aligned with, more reproductive of the specifically capitalist organization of enterprises and the economy as a whole. I am less clear on why you would want to go to relatively unusual mechanisms (at least these days) such as digital muni currency or demurrage charges if your goal is to "fund worker-owned/run businesses." Most tax systems could raise the money needed to support what we call WSDEs (workers self-directed enterprises). The support can include one or more of the following: buying WSDE outputs, lending to WSDEs below market rates, investing in WSDEs, subsidizing them by lowering their input costs, providing free or low cost consulting services, training employees, and so on. In doing any or all of these things, government (at any level: municipal, state, federal) would be providing to WSDEs the same set of supports that governments have provided to capitalist enterprises over the last 300 years. One could, of course, explore how muni currencies of various sorts might facilitate the development of a ESDE sector.

2 comments Share

Pension Scheme for WSDE workers

Dr Wolff, I am from Melbourne Australia. I have read your book Democracy At Work from cover to cover. However I have found that no references have been made for retirement arrangements or a pension scheme for the members of WSDEs. Could you please explain how that works.

Richard Wolff posted an official response

There are, with an economy based on WSDEs, a variety of ways to organize pension systems (as indeed there has proved to be a variety within capitalist systems). For an existing system built and refined over half a century, you can look at the Mondragon Cooperative Corporation's very well documented system. Another way would be to allocate a portion of a worker coop's net revenues as a fund to be used to make pension payments to retired WSDE workers. This raises the question of how such a fund would be invested over the time that the worker is working. And here multiple possibilities likewise exist. It could be cautiously invested in govt bonds and/or it could be invested, part or whole, in loans at interest to new start-up WSDE's thereby constituting a fund that was both aimed at pension provision but also WSDE growth. Witholding of contributions into such a pension fund could come from individual WSDE members' wage income and/or from net income of the WSDE (total revenues minus wage and other input costs). An interesting concept that some WSDE's have developed entails rethinking what "retirement" means. Here the idea is that individual workers would be offered a situation somewhere between regular work and full retirement with a whole network of full-time and varying part-time tasks needed by the community of WSDEs that would be partly paid as all regular workers are paid and partly funded out of pension fund disbursements. In sum, no special problems attach to WSDE's in terms of establishing, funding and managing a pension fund system.

2 comments Share

How to interest young people in saving Social Security?

Dr. Wolff, I live in Southern California and witnessed unbelievable levels of homelessness and despair among young people during road trips I have taken throughout the West in the past two years. In the age of the "gig economy" where Uber runs radio spots urging people to get their "side hustles" going, young folk have no security in the present and face a bleak future if Trump and the austerity hucksters have tbeir way. How can the young be reached and, most importantly, be mobilized? The mendacious memes of Paul Ryan, who claims he wants to save Social Security, need to be effectively neutralized (Trumped. If you will).

Richard Wolff posted an official response

An old man, Bernie Sanders, galvanized millions of young people into a powerful political force. The young can be reached by anyone who has (1) a solid critique of the political economy of a declining US capitalism, and (2) a reasonable plan of what changes to make to give young people (and everyone else) real hope for the future. If we do that, the young will be moved, excited not only to save Social Security but to make the many other changes this country so badly needs. I do a good bit of public speaking and traveling around the US and my audiences include a growing number of young folks, more all the time. The politics represented by Clinton and Trump are making their ugly last gasps. The component of the young in the mass demonstrations across the country against Trump's actions on refugees is yet another sign of what is possible. Organization to mobilize: that is the key next step.

4 comments Share

Is this the crux of the religious rights political thinking?

Would like to know what you think of the Tellus Institutet and a teleconference which is particularly interesting to us "homemakers". Also, I happened upon a frightful muddle of "alternate facts" that begs to be straightened out (by you?).  I remember parents talking like this 40 years ago in Maine.
Comment Share

Guaranteed minimum income

Are there any studies or statistics you know of that compare the costs of subsidizing (mostly corporations, of course) and workers competing for increasingly scarce and increasingly lower-paid jobs with providing a Guaranteed Minimum Income? 

I take your point about splitting society into workers and non-working consumers. That potential political-philosophical problem could be solved by a revolution in how we think about work and about unemployment. I direct any interested people to Ivan Illich's "The Right To Useful Unemployment." 

I see no absolute virtue in work for the sake of work. Our society mistakenly conflates purpose and work. There are a vast number of soul-sucking jobs that people, given an alternative, would leave to pursue their dreams if they could, which would benefit us all.

 

Richard Wolff posted an official response

Probably are such statistical efforts but they depend on myjriad assumptions and are always contested endlessly. On the point of work/non work dichotomy as socially divisive, that would apply to almost any definition of work unless it was tantamount to equal with non-work. Hegelian complexity but true nevertheless.

2 comments Share


Is the Calexit a good idea?

It looks like California has different views on Tax, Education, Religion, etc. Could California benefits by separating itself from the Union? or a terrible idea? who would really benefit from it?

Richard Wolff posted an official response

Having not ever really looked into this, I cannot offer you much in the way of an answer. Sorry about that. What I can say is that as global capitalism's relentless instability and inequality worsen, all kinds of rising anxieties push people to rethink their situations, loyalties, etc. They question assumptions they took for granted. One of those is nationality. That can take the form of the rise of extreme nationalist political movements and parties (eg., Trump, Farage, LePen among many others) and/or kinds of nationalism built around units smaller than currently constituted nations such as Scotland, Catalonia, Macedonia, Quebec, and now California as well as Texas. These are signs of socio-economic decline.

2 comments Share

connect